For me…Sometimes questioning and playing with the different varieties is part of the hobby. I think if we all had this figured out it wouldn’t be as much fun . My $0.02 anywayDespite my questioning at times whether this is, in fact, a Mt Etna, I am going to agree with you and others who think this is a Mt Etna.
I got this one accidentally (mistaken ID). It is my earliest Etna. Period. The hang time is really short. It survives the winter fine and when picked dead ripe is about as good as any Mt. Etna gets; they have some different nuances, but it will keep its in ground real estate at my home. Oh and it’s the only Etna that held all of its Breba after our spring killer frost.I rooted this one last year, haven't tried it yet though.
If it is the same as the others...it may be gifted as well.
I just don't need anymore Etnas.
15g pots should be big enough for first or even 2nd year but your season is long(with the indoor headstart) I do know someone with couple rooted cuttings filled out 15g pots in one season in CA. It is possible to have breba in a first year cutting if it is near the bottom. Crozes are not usually considered big.It's possible, though most of them go into 15g pots by 7-8 months of the first year, or the following year, so there is plenty of root space. Crozes was up-potted to 15g. Interestingly, my 1st year I-258 grew some really large figs, in the 65-110g range, which clearly was not normal, I think some were breba type figs, which is common for first year trees. The size was normal - in the typical range - the following year.
My newly rooted Crozes actually set a few brebas at the bottom of the trunk. I posted pictures on the other forum last year, and most agreed it was not main crop but breba. Those were very large. The rest were smaller, looked like typical Crozes main crop, but clearly larger than other growers had experienced. I recall a few growers complained that their Crozes were a 'small' fig, which was not the case with my Crozes. That's another reason I want to see how it turns out this year, is it going to maintain the size or get smaller, similar to what other growers reported as their 'normal' size.
Well dang that's good news, thanks.I got this one accidentally (mistaken ID). It is my earliest Etna. Period. The hang time is really short. It survives the winter fine and when picked dead ripe is about as good as any Mt. Etna gets; they have some different nuances, but it will keep its in ground real estate at my home. Oh and it’s the only Etna that held all of its Breba after our spring killer frost.
@superdave336 actually he has. You can get 1-2 varieties through Off The Beaten Path. He is starting to distribute through Bill.Lou keeps saying he is going to share with the fig community but to my knowledge he never has…lol. Hopefully one day.
I know he has that big Celeste tree there but i wasn’t aware of any other trees. That’s good then. Hopefully he will do more.@superdave336 actually he has. You can get 1-2 varieties threw Off The Beaten Path. He is starting to distribute through Bill.
I remember on Almost Eden Plants they had a variety I believe called giant Celeste. They described it as Celeste on steroids. Last time I was at their website I didn’t see it listed.Found 1 variety, the big celeste
![]()
Chincoteague Celeste
This is a discovery by Lou Monti. It is an excellent extra large celeste with a distinct berry flavor. We both love it. The mother tree is immense. Excellent figs that do not split.offthebeatenpathnursery.com
I’m pretty sure … never had any winter damage until this year.This tree that Lou calls Mt Etna Unknown sounds like a good one. In 7a it has never had any winter damage unprotected. It's so early that it is ripening at the same time as RdB. I don't know how many people have gotten cuttings from that tree. Seems like one that should be shared with the fig community, if it hasn't already.
This is pretty much it. Taste wise, everyone is different, even in one household the taste buds are different. So, it’s a juggling act between what one likes, and what does well in your area.The best ‘Etna’ for you is so dependent on your climate (zone, humidity, potted or in-ground), your taste, and individual tree variation, that a lot if time it falls to trial and error. I thought this video comparison was good—
I have RLBV and Malta Black started this year to bolster my Hardy Chicago. I have had MB before here and it did well until I killed it. RLBV was available so I also got it. (I have grown many strains of HC as well as Sal’s EL, MB, and MBVS but not the more exotic strains). I think researching everyone else’s favorite Etnas will just give you a headache, you have to trial your best shots.