What are top tier fig varieties? I am not taking about new hyped up figs. Is it quality of fruit? Combination of vigor, cold hardiness, and taste? I am new to growing figs but I think my VdB is a top tier fig.
It seems that what 'top tier fig' is often very much dependent on one's definition. There are a few of those definitions it seems. If you've never tasted a truly premium fig, you will be inclined to put your top-tasting figs into that category. I once read on the other person an experience grower say 'a well-ripened RDB is as good as it gets'. And that's fine, but that won't make them top tier in absolute terms. A Ferrarri is a top-tier sports car, there is no argument with that. A Mazda Miata isn't. If all one can drive/afford is a Miata, it doesn't make it a top-tier sports car. It's a nice car, affordable. Maybe fun to drive too, in way. But let's be realistic.
For me, a top-tier fig is a fig with the highest taste qualities. Great texture. Great flavor. Multidimensional, layered, and nuanced flavor. Long finish. Great aftertaste.
There are figs that fall into that category somewhat automatically because of the widespread support of that reputation by the majority of growers. E.g. Black Madeira/Black Madeira synonyms, BNR, CLBC, CDDs, I-258, Martinenca Rimada, caprified Panache, Boysenberry Blush. etc.
Then there are those that may have less unanimous support but still come close, depending on who you ask. E.g. DSJG, Calderona, Figo Roxo, Paratjal Rimada, Borda Barraquer, Angelito, WM#1, IBG, Bourgasotte Grise, NDB, etc.
I personally wouldn't call my VDB top tier, and I love it. It's a fantastic fig. Very tasty. Excellent flavor.
But it doesn't have the same refined taste, same flavor complexity, and the same texture to compete with, say, I-258 or Black Madeira. My 2 cents.